Emotional Meditation—By Micah Siemens
There is a particular kind of pain that doesn’t come from sin, or rebellion, or obvious failure. It comes from confusion. Psalm 44 turns sharply here—almost abruptly—as if the psalmist is still holding the memories of God’s faithfulness in one hand while staring at present defeat with the other.
“But You have rejected us and disgraced us and have not gone out with our armies.”
That but carries weight. It’s the sound of a story breaking mid-sentence. The sound of faith colliding with lived reality. You can feel the disorientation. This isn’t a people who abandoned God. This is a people who trusted Him—and still lost. Sometimes that’s the hardest place to live spiritually. Perhaps you have experienced versions of this yourself—doing what felt faithful, praying honestly, seeking God carefully, and still watching things unravel or stall or remain unanswered. Psalm 44 gives you language for that moment—when you don’t know what you did wrong, but you know something feels deeply wrong.
“You have made us turn back from the foe, and those who hate us have taken spoil.”
There’s vulnerability here. Defeat strips away illusion. It leaves you exposed, aware of how thin your strength really is. Then the psalm moves from private pain to public shame:
“You have made us a taunt to our neighbors, mocked and derided by those around us.”
Suffering is hard enough when it’s quiet. But when it becomes visible—when others see your weakness—it cuts deeper. I know that ache: when my faith, my calling, my hopes feel questioned by others. When silence from God becomes loud commentary from the world. The psalmist doesn’t rush past this humiliation. He sits in it. Names it. Feels it.
“All day long my disgrace is before me, and shame has covered my face.”
This is the anatomy of discouragement—the way it follows you throughout the day, the way it colors your thoughts, the way it seeps into identity if you let it. And here’s the quiet pastoral truth this section offers: God allows His people to speak this honestly without rebuke. Psalm 44:9–16 does not get interrupted by correction. There is no divine voice saying, “You shouldn’t feel this way.” No rush to explain the mystery. Just space. Space to grieve. Space to question. Space to admit that faith doesn’t always shield us from confusion. This psalm reminds you and me that wrestling with God is not the same as walking away from Him. In fact, the very act of speaking this pain to God is proof that trust still exists. Psalm 44 doesn’t deny God’s past faithfulness. It just refuses to pretend that the present doesn’t hurt. And sometimes, the most faithful thing you can do is tell the truth about the pain and stay in the conversation anyway.
Leave a comment